Cheese Substitutions List
Is this a situation you've experienced? You have several cheeses in the refrigerator and you're in the mood for a particular recipe, but you don't have the cheese the recipe calls for. You don't want to buy more cheese until your current "stock" diminishes a bit. What to do? Fear not! It's possible—even easy—to substitute some cheeses for others with very good results.
Here are our suggestions for Wisconsin cheese substitutions. We're not promising the dish will taste the same, but we think it will taste very good, and the texture of the suggested cheeses will be fine as well. Certainly, not having a specific cheese shouldn't prevent you from creating a winning dish for everyday occasions. When ethnic authenticity is important, or you want to emulate exactly a chef's dish, it's best to buy the specified cheese.
| The recipe calls for | Wisconsin Cheese(s) you can use |
| Gouda | Edam |
| Colby | Mild Cheddar, CoJack |
| Queso Oaxaca | Mozzarella (preferred) or Monterey Jack |
| Asadero, Queso Quesadilla, Queso | Feta, salty Farmers' cheese |
| Chihuahua | Muenster, Monterey Jack |
| Gruyere | Swiss (preferably aged) |
| Raclette | Gruyere, Aged Swiss |
| American | Mild Cheddar |
| Muenster | Monterey Jack, Gouda |
| Gorgonzola | Creamy, mild Blue |
| Butterkase | Havarti |
| Manchego | Fontina of similar age, Gouda |
| Roquefort | Pungent, salty Blue |
| Parmigiano-Reggiano, Grana Padano | Parmesan |
| Fontina | Mild Provolone, Muenster |
| Asiago | Parmesan |
| Camembert | Brie |
| Cotija | Romano, Parmesan |
| Burrata | Fresh Mozzarella |
| Scamorza | Whole Milk Mozzarella |
| Mascarpone | Whipped Cream Cheese |
| Justo Liepa | Bread Cheese |
| Brick | Muenster, havarti |
| Farmer Cheese | Light-tasting Havarti |
| Pepato | Parmesan or Romano and black peppercorn |
Wisconsin Cheesemakers make a number of Wisconsin Originals cheeses. We've listed some that are most widely available and given alternates in case you cannot find them.
| The recipe calls for | Wisconsin Cheese(s) you can use |
| Pleasant Ridge Reserve | Gruyere, Aged Swiss |
| Vintage Van Gogh | Aged Gouda |
| Gran Queso | Italian-style Fontina |
| Gran Canaria | Another aged Wisconsin mixed (cow's and/or goat and sheep's) milk cheese |
| American Grana | Parmesan |
| Wisconsin Emmentaler | Swiss |
| Bellavitano | Young, creamy Asiago |
| Les Frères | Limburger |