Cheese Substitutions List

Is this a situation you've experienced? You have several cheeses in the refrigerator and you're in the mood for a particular recipe, but you don't have the cheese the recipe calls for. You don't want to buy more cheese until your current "stock" diminishes a bit. What to do? Fear not! It's possible—even easy—to substitute some cheeses for others with very good results.

Here are our suggestions for Wisconsin cheese substitutions. We're not promising the dish will taste the same, but we think it will taste very good, and the texture of the suggested cheeses will be fine as well. Certainly, not having a specific cheese shouldn't prevent you from creating a winning dish for everyday occasions. When ethnic authenticity is important, or you want to emulate exactly a chef's dish, it's best to buy the specified cheese.

The recipe calls for
Wisconsin Cheese(s) you can use
Gouda
Edam
Colby
Mild Cheddar, CoJack
Queso Oaxaca
Mozzarella (preferred) or Monterey Jack
Asadero, Queso Quesadilla, Queso
Feta, salty Farmers' cheese
Chihuahua
Muenster, Monterey Jack
Gruyere
Swiss (preferably aged)
Raclette
Gruyere, Aged Swiss
American
Mild Cheddar
Muenster
Monterey Jack, Gouda
Gorgonzola
Creamy, mild Blue
Butterkase
Havarti
Manchego
Fontina of similar age, Gouda
Roquefort
Pungent, salty Blue
Parmigiano-Reggiano, Grana Padano
Parmesan
Fontina
Mild Provolone, Muenster
Asiago
Parmesan
Camembert
Brie
Cotija
Romano, Parmesan
Burrata
Fresh Mozzarella
Scamorza
Whole Milk Mozzarella
Mascarpone
Whipped Cream Cheese
Justo Liepa
Bread Cheese
Brick
Muenster, havarti
Farmer Cheese
Light-tasting Havarti
Pepato
Parmesan or Romano and black peppercorn

 
Wisconsin Cheesemakers make a number of Wisconsin Originals cheeses. We've listed some that are most widely available and given alternates in case you cannot find them.

The recipe calls for
Wisconsin Cheese(s) you can use
Pleasant Ridge Reserve
Gruyere, Aged Swiss
Vintage Van Gogh
Aged Gouda
Gran Queso
Italian-style Fontina
Gran Canaria
Another aged Wisconsin mixed (cow's and/or goat and sheep's) milk cheese
American Grana
Parmesan
Wisconsin Emmentaler
Swiss
Bellavitano
Young, creamy Asiago
Les Frères
Limburger